CPHA Canvax
CPHA Canvax
PDF
Abstract

Introduction
Since the 1990s strenuous attempts have been made to rebuild trust in childhood immunisations. This study aimed to understand if financial incentives (FI) or quasi-mandatory schemes (QMS), e.g. mandating immunisations for entry to universal services such as day care or school, might be acceptable interventions to increase immunisations uptake for preschool children.

Material and methods
Parents and carers of preschool children (n = 91); health and other professionals (n = 18); and those responsible for developing and commissioning immunisation services (n = 6) took part in the study. Qualitative methods were employed to explore the acceptability of FI/QMS with stakeholders. Framework analysis was used to develop a coding framework that was applied to the whole dataset. Interpretations of the emergent themes were verified between researchers and presented to the project's Parent Reference Group to ensure coherence and relevance.

Results
(1) FI: parents and professionals felt introducing FI was inappropriate. It was acknowledged FI may encourage families living in disadvantage to prioritise immunisation, but unintended consequences could outweigh any advantage. FI essentially changes behaviour into a cash transaction which many equated to bribery that could inadvertently create inequalities.

(2) QMS: parents and professionals highlighted the positives of introducing QMS, stating it felt natural, fair and less likely to create inequality. Despite QMS’ potential to positively impact on uptake there were concerns about the implementation and workability of such schemes.

Discussion and conclusion
FI for preschool immunisation may not be acceptable, within a UK context. Introducing FI could have detrimental effects on uptake if it were associated with bribery and coercion. Quasi-mandatory schemes, mandating immunisation for universal service entry, was the most acceptable option and could contribute to the normalising of immunisation. Future work would be needed to assess how this could be successfully implemented and if it did indeed increase uptake.


Téléchargement

Ressources connexes

Signet

Données probantes

PDF

Catégorie

Politiques,Politiques de vaccination,Immunisation obligatoires et des activités de vaccination Politiques
Politiques de vaccination
Immunisation obligatoires et des activités de vaccination

0 Commentaires

Dans la boîte de commentaires ci-dessous, dites-nous ce que vous pensez de cette ressource. Dites à la communauté de l’utilisation quel usage vous en avez fait, ce qui a fonctionné ou pas, et les changements que vous avez apportés. La rétroaction obtenue contribuera à informer les membres de la communauté de l’immunisation et à améliorer cette ressource que le CANVax met à leur disposition.

Les commentaires sont anonymes. Les commentaires déposés seront soumis à l’approbation de l’équipe du CANVax pour s’assurer qu’ils respectent les consignes de soumission de contenu. Veuillez noter que l’équipe du CANVax tente d’approuver les commentaires dans les meilleurs délais, mais qu’il peut y avoir des retards en raison du volume.